A four-year paper trail of contradictions: how Australia’s drug regulator promised transparency on Covid-19 vaccine safety, then lost track of its own oversight.
Maryanne, Very Australian. Always allowing that it is just confusion or bumbling that is leading to nothing working the way it should. I would suggest that these are evil people doing evil things would be a far more credible (and likely correct) explanation for everything exposed here.
I agree. The TGA’s behaviour is despicable. Like these authors, I’ve gone down this path—submitting FOI requests and uncovering what can only be described as deliberate, calculated obstruction. These are not just bureaucratic failings; they are acts of bad faith by people within the very agency entrusted with Australians’ safety.
There were 3 possible explanations presented as to why the TGA can’t (won’t?) produce straight forward documentation re enhanced monitoring. Could a fourth be that the information would be too damning and they would have no answer as to why they didn’t pull these products from the market?
Enlightening quote MaryAnne Senator Katy Gallagher dismissed the motion as “another trawling expedition from an anti-vaccination Senator” and said production would be an “unacceptable diversion of departmental resources.”
Why does Labor let the people down. Are they in the pocket of Pfizer Inc (or Pfizer Australia pty Ltd - board member of Medicines Australia sitting next to John Skerritt retired TGA Boss
Katy Gallagher is disgusting. In parliament even last year she repeated the total lie that the unvaxxed were 30 times more likely to pass on covid - a claim which has never ever been backed up, and as we know, is completely false based on study after study we have available.
But I digress. Katys claims about time wasting are completely wrong. If there is a process that has to be followed then it needs to be followed. Yes, the TGA would love to do just what it wants to do, but this is what it NEEDS to do. And if people and depts don't do what they NEED to do then politicians should not provide cover for them.
Australia is in a very bad place where an ever expanding horde of unelected officials carry out largely wasteful and unneeded actions, and refuse to be held accountable. If this were a listed company the board would have been sacked and the share price would be in free fall as governance had completely failed - but because its a govt dept they apparently can do whatever they want.
Basically we need a Reformation of Australia to completely recast our systems so that the TGA and others cannot wilfully flout legal and ethical requirements. In fact I would go so far as to ask why we even need a TGA anyway.
No fulfilment of the continued monitoring in today’s article by Maryanne.
The Morrison Govt and National Cabinet secrecy could have been cut open = dissected by Labor - they had TEALs seeking transparency via corruption commission NACC but ALP have waved through so much TGA corruption (a spade a spade because that is what it is)
Covid treatment in community was another provisional approval. PAXLOVID & LAGEVRIO
How could TGA in August 2024 change PAXLOVID to full approval whilst not even mentioning EPIC-SR trial failure documented by NEJM in publication not only 4 months before that full approval but a month before the DECIDING committee met in May 2024. PLUS Pfizer Inc had the results in 2023 but sponsor Pfizer Australia Pty Ltd chose not to include the results of p=0.6 v placebo for standard risk some vaccinated or subgroup high risk all vaccinated - NOT A MENTION. The full approval was based on EPIC-HR ALL UNVACCINATED- so relevant for Australia!! and not one other consideration than John Skerritt used in exempting himself from LEGISLATIVE requirements on 20 Jan 2022. No fulfilment of the continued monitoring in today’s article by Maryanne.
Why isn’t TGA broken up - it needs a Royal Commission and Morrison National Cabinet decisions before they legislated to avoid cabinet paper scrutiny after Rex Patrick High Court win - anything before December 2021 can have FOI …
Re: "Millions of Australians received provisionally approved vaccines under policies that cost people their livelihoods, divided families, and restricted access to society."
Millions of Australian received 'provisionally approved vaccines', but Brendan Murphy, then Secretary of the Australian Department of Health, publicly misled/mis/disinformed Australians about this in his conversation with Leigh Sales on the ABC's 7.30 program on 3 February 2021.
In his response to Leigh Sales' questions: "...what is your message to any Australian who might be legitimately worried thinking, "This has happened all pretty quickly. I'm sort of worried. Is it going to be safe to have a vaccine? What is your official advice on that?""
Brendan Murphy responded by assuring the audience that the Pfizer and AstraZeneca vaccine products had "gone through the normal, full range of regulatory approvals for our vaccines...we have been able to do the full, safe, regulatory approval...we have not cut any corners" and "...we decided that to get the confidence of the people in Australia, because we had no community transmission, we were not going to do anything other than our full normal registration process".
Someone listening to this discussion between Brendan Murphy and Leigh Sales, they are hearing that the vaccine products have "gone through the normal, full range of regulatory approvals"..."we have not cut any corners".
And yet, according to the TGA's provisional approval statements re the vaccines, the TGA was relying on Pfizer and AstraZeneca "to continue providing information to the TGA on longer term efficacy and safety from ongoing clinical trials and post market assessment". The TGA's provisional approval statements also noted "it is not yet known whether it [the vaccine] prevents transmission or asymptomatic disease".
Just think about that!!!
In February 2021 the TGA was relying on information from the manufacturers re efficacy and safety...and post market assessment...which apparently didn't happen.
This is such a massive scandal, so much to be exposed here!
Let's start with Brendan Murphy publicly giving Australians the impression the vaccines had been 'fully approved', when in fact they had not, and when the TGA was self-admittedly relying on manufacturers' data...and post market assessment.
'Post market assessment'...the euphemism for experimenting on the community, without valid voluntary informed consent, and apparently no authentic follow-up.
It appears bureaucracies are the same everywhere! Im hoping the US will get this sorted out, but it’s an uphill climb for Bobby Kennedy and his team. There are still some evil people trying to wreak everything he is trying to do.
This just leaves me astounded. The results must be so bad that it would maybe bring down a government. We listened to their lies during and after covid and saw a weak ineffective enquiry. Now the TGA is breaking the law by failing to live up to reporting this very serious issue. So thankful for all you determined people and Senator Robert’s and Antic. You all work so hard to uncover the truth.
I'm guessing that this lot were working from home or at least pretending to work from home. All sorts of distractions, the refrigerator, the internet, the necessity to take long "mental health" breaks. The days when the civil service employed the best and the brightest are long gone if they ever existed. And then there's the demon DEI protocols where merit goes out the window, How do you put all that together? You don't because you can't. It's beyond you--so you obfuscate, you cover up. And don't get me wrong, I'm not making excuses for them, I'm not saying that this isn't evil. And it's everywhere. Here in Canada the Trudeau regime increased the size of the civil service by 40% during the course of a decade and meanwhile productivity and competence have steadily eroded. Ugh.
And just when you think the TEAL senator might help - the staffer at the door tells an ACT resident they used to work in TGA and it’s a really good organisation and without any realisation of conflict that person admits to contributing Covid decisions. Immunity expands to the brains of PS ..
Re: "Because the COVID-19 vaccines received only “provisional” approval based on limited data..."
In other words, the COVID-19 vaccine rollout was an experiment upon the community, as personally admitted by then Health Minister Greg Hunt in conversation with the ABC's David Speers: "The world is engaged in the largest clinical trial, the largest global vaccination trial ever, and we will have enormous amounts of data."*
The world was "engaged in the largest clinical trial, the largest global vaccination trial ever"...without valid voluntary informed consent...
In fact, in Australia, people were mandated to participate in this "largest global vaccination trial ever" under threat of penalty for non-compliance, i.e. loss of livelihood and participation in society.
This is seriously the biggest crime of all time, it's impacted on millions/billions of people around the world, stealing personal autonomy and bodily integrity.
A deliberately manufactured crisis, based on a purported disease threat which wasn't actually a threat for most people, with the apparent aim of making people submit to vaccination on government demand, and to ensnare and enslave people in a social credit system.
Wow!!!
And who was instrumental in implementing this plan?
The medical 'profession', members of which - the doctors, the nurses, the pharmacists - who in the main went along with injecting people under coercion and mandates, failing to question the 'safe and effective' mantra.
It's mind-boggling!!!
And who is ultimately going to be thrown under the bus for this mass population assault by needles and 'vaccines'? I suggest it's going to be those vaccinating practitioners wielding the needles, who trashed their own personal obligation to obtain valid voluntary informed consent for medical interventions, those who wholeheartedly injected people they knew were under coercion and mandates to comply.
Yes, Speers, another "unwitting mouthpiece for the machine"...
The machine that terrorised and misled people about a deliberately manufactured crisis which was used to steal the freedom of the people, and sink them into billions of dollars of debt, theft on a ginormous scale.
Who is responsible for this, and who helped facilitate it?
Antic, Roberts, and Rennick, however well meaning, only serve to drive public discussion into a ditch. One entire side of politics - the side that traditionally cares about public health - completely switches off, or indeed instinctively takes the opposing side in a given debate, when either of those three represent a view. Greens and local Labor members should be called upon at every opportunity to advocate for the public interest, and escalate from there if they fail to do their jobs.
Maryanne, Very Australian. Always allowing that it is just confusion or bumbling that is leading to nothing working the way it should. I would suggest that these are evil people doing evil things would be a far more credible (and likely correct) explanation for everything exposed here.
I agree. The TGA’s behaviour is despicable. Like these authors, I’ve gone down this path—submitting FOI requests and uncovering what can only be described as deliberate, calculated obstruction. These are not just bureaucratic failings; they are acts of bad faith by people within the very agency entrusted with Australians’ safety.
There were 3 possible explanations presented as to why the TGA can’t (won’t?) produce straight forward documentation re enhanced monitoring. Could a fourth be that the information would be too damning and they would have no answer as to why they didn’t pull these products from the market?
I’d go with the 4th option. ☺️
And a fifth when you rely on manufacturer data - everything is redacted as commercial in confidence and seeks permission from perpetrators
Absolutely
Enlightening quote MaryAnne Senator Katy Gallagher dismissed the motion as “another trawling expedition from an anti-vaccination Senator” and said production would be an “unacceptable diversion of departmental resources.”
Why does Labor let the people down. Are they in the pocket of Pfizer Inc (or Pfizer Australia pty Ltd - board member of Medicines Australia sitting next to John Skerritt retired TGA Boss
The banality of evil.
Katy Gallagher is disgusting. In parliament even last year she repeated the total lie that the unvaxxed were 30 times more likely to pass on covid - a claim which has never ever been backed up, and as we know, is completely false based on study after study we have available.
But I digress. Katys claims about time wasting are completely wrong. If there is a process that has to be followed then it needs to be followed. Yes, the TGA would love to do just what it wants to do, but this is what it NEEDS to do. And if people and depts don't do what they NEED to do then politicians should not provide cover for them.
Australia is in a very bad place where an ever expanding horde of unelected officials carry out largely wasteful and unneeded actions, and refuse to be held accountable. If this were a listed company the board would have been sacked and the share price would be in free fall as governance had completely failed - but because its a govt dept they apparently can do whatever they want.
Basically we need a Reformation of Australia to completely recast our systems so that the TGA and others cannot wilfully flout legal and ethical requirements. In fact I would go so far as to ask why we even need a TGA anyway.
Yep, it's diabolical.
Another example - Covid treatments
No fulfilment of the continued monitoring in today’s article by Maryanne.
The Morrison Govt and National Cabinet secrecy could have been cut open = dissected by Labor - they had TEALs seeking transparency via corruption commission NACC but ALP have waved through so much TGA corruption (a spade a spade because that is what it is)
Covid treatment in community was another provisional approval. PAXLOVID & LAGEVRIO
How could TGA in August 2024 change PAXLOVID to full approval whilst not even mentioning EPIC-SR trial failure documented by NEJM in publication not only 4 months before that full approval but a month before the DECIDING committee met in May 2024. PLUS Pfizer Inc had the results in 2023 but sponsor Pfizer Australia Pty Ltd chose not to include the results of p=0.6 v placebo for standard risk some vaccinated or subgroup high risk all vaccinated - NOT A MENTION. The full approval was based on EPIC-HR ALL UNVACCINATED- so relevant for Australia!! and not one other consideration than John Skerritt used in exempting himself from LEGISLATIVE requirements on 20 Jan 2022. No fulfilment of the continued monitoring in today’s article by Maryanne.
Why isn’t TGA broken up - it needs a Royal Commission and Morrison National Cabinet decisions before they legislated to avoid cabinet paper scrutiny after Rex Patrick High Court win - anything before December 2021 can have FOI …
Good idea. But there would need be integrity in the system to do that.
Re: "Millions of Australians received provisionally approved vaccines under policies that cost people their livelihoods, divided families, and restricted access to society."
Millions of Australian received 'provisionally approved vaccines', but Brendan Murphy, then Secretary of the Australian Department of Health, publicly misled/mis/disinformed Australians about this in his conversation with Leigh Sales on the ABC's 7.30 program on 3 February 2021.
In his response to Leigh Sales' questions: "...what is your message to any Australian who might be legitimately worried thinking, "This has happened all pretty quickly. I'm sort of worried. Is it going to be safe to have a vaccine? What is your official advice on that?""
Brendan Murphy responded by assuring the audience that the Pfizer and AstraZeneca vaccine products had "gone through the normal, full range of regulatory approvals for our vaccines...we have been able to do the full, safe, regulatory approval...we have not cut any corners" and "...we decided that to get the confidence of the people in Australia, because we had no community transmission, we were not going to do anything other than our full normal registration process".
Someone listening to this discussion between Brendan Murphy and Leigh Sales, they are hearing that the vaccine products have "gone through the normal, full range of regulatory approvals"..."we have not cut any corners".
And yet, according to the TGA's provisional approval statements re the vaccines, the TGA was relying on Pfizer and AstraZeneca "to continue providing information to the TGA on longer term efficacy and safety from ongoing clinical trials and post market assessment". The TGA's provisional approval statements also noted "it is not yet known whether it [the vaccine] prevents transmission or asymptomatic disease".
Just think about that!!!
In February 2021 the TGA was relying on information from the manufacturers re efficacy and safety...and post market assessment...which apparently didn't happen.
This is such a massive scandal, so much to be exposed here!
Let's start with Brendan Murphy publicly giving Australians the impression the vaccines had been 'fully approved', when in fact they had not, and when the TGA was self-admittedly relying on manufacturers' data...and post market assessment.
'Post market assessment'...the euphemism for experimenting on the community, without valid voluntary informed consent, and apparently no authentic follow-up.
I wrote to Brendan Murphy in February 2021, calling him out, see: COVID-19 vaccines are NOT fully approved by the TGA: https://vaccinationispolitical.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/covid-19-vaccines-are-not-fully-approved-by-the-tga.pdf
I also raised this with the ABC in March 2021...which did nothing to address the matter as far as I'm aware, see my email to David Anderson, then ABC Managing Director: Re: Misleading information - Brendan Murphy's interview with Leigh Sales: https://vaccinationispolitical.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/misleading-information-brendan-murphys-interview-with-abc-leigh-sales.pdf
And I also raised the matter in a message to then Prime Minister Scott Morrison in March 2021, see: Misleading information about COVID-19 vaccine products from Australian Health Secretary Brendan Murphy: https://vaccinationispolitical.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/misleading-information-about-covid-19-vaccine-products-from-australian-health-secretary-brendan-murphy.pdf
You could not make up how bad this is... The Australian public has been abused and exploited from all sides.
It appears bureaucracies are the same everywhere! Im hoping the US will get this sorted out, but it’s an uphill climb for Bobby Kennedy and his team. There are still some evil people trying to wreak everything he is trying to do.
Yes, there’s still so much resistance from the old guard within.
This just leaves me astounded. The results must be so bad that it would maybe bring down a government. We listened to their lies during and after covid and saw a weak ineffective enquiry. Now the TGA is breaking the law by failing to live up to reporting this very serious issue. So thankful for all you determined people and Senator Robert’s and Antic. You all work so hard to uncover the truth.
They will use every trick in the book to avoid accountability. It’s infuriating.
But PWC management consultants were involved in distributing so it must be ok 👍
I'm guessing that this lot were working from home or at least pretending to work from home. All sorts of distractions, the refrigerator, the internet, the necessity to take long "mental health" breaks. The days when the civil service employed the best and the brightest are long gone if they ever existed. And then there's the demon DEI protocols where merit goes out the window, How do you put all that together? You don't because you can't. It's beyond you--so you obfuscate, you cover up. And don't get me wrong, I'm not making excuses for them, I'm not saying that this isn't evil. And it's everywhere. Here in Canada the Trudeau regime increased the size of the civil service by 40% during the course of a decade and meanwhile productivity and competence have steadily eroded. Ugh.
Agree, our government agencies are bloated and incompetent.
And just when you think the TEAL senator might help - the staffer at the door tells an ACT resident they used to work in TGA and it’s a really good organisation and without any realisation of conflict that person admits to contributing Covid decisions. Immunity expands to the brains of PS ..
🤯
The life of a well paid emoji
Re: "Because the COVID-19 vaccines received only “provisional” approval based on limited data..."
In other words, the COVID-19 vaccine rollout was an experiment upon the community, as personally admitted by then Health Minister Greg Hunt in conversation with the ABC's David Speers: "The world is engaged in the largest clinical trial, the largest global vaccination trial ever, and we will have enormous amounts of data."*
The world was "engaged in the largest clinical trial, the largest global vaccination trial ever"...without valid voluntary informed consent...
In fact, in Australia, people were mandated to participate in this "largest global vaccination trial ever" under threat of penalty for non-compliance, i.e. loss of livelihood and participation in society.
This is seriously the biggest crime of all time, it's impacted on millions/billions of people around the world, stealing personal autonomy and bodily integrity.
A deliberately manufactured crisis, based on a purported disease threat which wasn't actually a threat for most people, with the apparent aim of making people submit to vaccination on government demand, and to ensnare and enslave people in a social credit system.
Wow!!!
And who was instrumental in implementing this plan?
The medical 'profession', members of which - the doctors, the nurses, the pharmacists - who in the main went along with injecting people under coercion and mandates, failing to question the 'safe and effective' mantra.
It's mind-boggling!!!
And who is ultimately going to be thrown under the bus for this mass population assault by needles and 'vaccines'? I suggest it's going to be those vaccinating practitioners wielding the needles, who trashed their own personal obligation to obtain valid voluntary informed consent for medical interventions, those who wholeheartedly injected people they knew were under coercion and mandates to comply.
The treachery is off the scale...
Reference: * Interview with David Speers on ABC Insiders on the COVID-19 vaccine rollout, 21 February 2021: https://www.health.gov.au/ministers/the-hon-greg-hunt-mp/media/interview-with-david-speers-on-abc-insiders-on-the-covid-19-vaccine-rollout
I also recall Speers chastising the government for not rolling out the vaccines fast enough — just another unwitting mouthpiece for the machine.
Yes, Speers, another "unwitting mouthpiece for the machine"...
The machine that terrorised and misled people about a deliberately manufactured crisis which was used to steal the freedom of the people, and sink them into billions of dollars of debt, theft on a ginormous scale.
Who is responsible for this, and who helped facilitate it?
This is what must be unravelled now.
Antic, Roberts, and Rennick, however well meaning, only serve to drive public discussion into a ditch. One entire side of politics - the side that traditionally cares about public health - completely switches off, or indeed instinctively takes the opposing side in a given debate, when either of those three represent a view. Greens and local Labor members should be called upon at every opportunity to advocate for the public interest, and escalate from there if they fail to do their jobs.